Wealth inequality in graphs

Nov 15 JDN 2461360

While the results of this year’s elections were mostly very good, there is one outcome that disappointed me: California’s ballot measure to institute a wealth tax on billionaires narrowly failed. I was also quite surprised by this, because wealth taxes on billionaires seem to be, in general, a very popular policy, especially among Democrats, who form a strong majority of California’s population. (The New York Times tries to make this into some kind of referendum on progressive policies in general, which seems… oddly defeatist. Okay, we didn’t get this one, this time; but after winning this many elections, you’re saying our policy agenda is hopeless?)

Perhaps time will tell what happened here: Did many people simply not vote on the proposal? Did they not understand it? Were the extensive and well-funded ad campaigns against the proposal effective at convincing people to oppose it? I don’t know.

What I do know is that we clearly need to do something about wealth inequality in this country.

If you look at the proportion of wealth owned by the 50%-90% percentiles, which we might think of as the “upper middle class”, there is a steady decline, but the absolute numbers still don’t seem so bad:

This group comprises 40% of the population, and in 1990 owned 36% of the wealth. Today, they own 29% of the wealth. That’s a definite decline, but 40% of people owning 29% of the wealth still doesn’t seem too unreasonable.

It’s when you look at the bottom 50%—everyone below the median wealth—that alarm bells start going off:

In 1990, this group—half the population, remember—owned only 3.5% of all US wealth. Today, it’s even worse: The lower half of the population owns only 2.5% of the wealth. And most of that is owned by the second quartile; the first quartile owns essentially zero net wealth—or even has negative net wealth.

What about the rich?

Well, what we might call the “merely rich”, the 90% to 99% percentiles, has been fairly stable in its wealth share, going from 38% of wealth in 1990 to 36.5% of wealth today. They comprise 9% of the population; so, roughly speaking, people in this group are about 4 times as wealthy as the average.

But then we get to the “very rich”, the top 1% excluding the top 0.1%, and we see a different story:

Their share of wealth has risen from 14% in 1990 to 17% today—and note that since they are only 1% of the population, this means they have gone from 14 times as rich as the average to 17 times as rich.

But even this is not the worst of our inequality. Finally, we come to the “super rich”, the top 0.1%, and the result is absolutely appalling:

Their share of US wealth has risen from 9% in 1990—already much too high—to over 15% today. Since they are only 0.1% of the population, this means their wealth has risen from 90 times the average to 150 times the average.

Combining this with the fall in wealth for the bottom half of the distribution, we find that the ratio in average wealth between someone in the top 0.1% and someone in the bottom 50% has risen from an already-staggering 1,285 to an utterly horrifying 3,000. The average person in the top 0.1% now owns three thousand times as much wealth as the average person in the poorest half of our country.

Many economists will tell you we should only be concerned about how poor the poor are, nevermind how rich the rich are—but I think this is wrong. I think when the richest of the rich own this much of our society’s wealth, they also take on a disproportionate amount of the power by their ability to run ads, control media, and donate to political campaigns.

Indeed, I think it may turn out that the very reason the billionaire tax failed was because of this disproportionate power—that the very reason we need the billionaire tax is the reason it didn’t quite make it.

We won the election. Now the real work begins.

Nov 10 JDN 2461355

Last Tuesday’s midterm elections honestly went better than I would have hoped for. Not only did Democrats take majorities in the House and the Senate, but several states attained a “trifecta” of governor, state house, and state senate all controlled by the Democrats—including Texas, which I was utterly shocked to see; they haven’t had a Democratic trifecta in decades. Even Mississippi and Alabama elected a number of Democrats, including a transgender woman in Alabama!

Of course I would have liked to reach a veto-proof 67 seats in the Senate, but that was always a very long shot; Democrats would have needed to win literally every seat that was up for election. (The Democrats had 32 seats not up for grabs, and there were 35 seats up for grabs, so getting to 67 would have required winning all 35. As it is, they won 22 and might win up to 2 more.) This went as well as could be reasonably hoped for, and it’s worth celebrating.

But this is not the end. It is only the beginning.

Now our task is to hold the Democrats accountable for repairing the damage Trump and the Republicans have done, and also for bringing to justice those in Trump’s administration—including himself—who have displayed blatant corruption, venality, and authoritarianism.

This won’t be easy: Without those 67 seats (which we almost certainly weren’t ever going to get), Trump can veto anything the Democrats pass, and will probably do so—but they should pass it anyway, and we need to make that clear to them. Passing popular bills that then Trump vetoes is yet another way to chip away at Trump’s remaining support. And in fact if Trump realizes this, he might even decide to sign some bills he’d rather veto, just to avoid the loss to his popularity. (Trump doesn’t care in the least about the welfare of the country, but his own popularity is one of the few things he does care about.)

There will be self-styled “moderates” and “centrists” who will tell us to let bygones be bygones. This is not centrism. True centrists defend democracy. Trump has clearly shown that he intends to undermine American democracy to serve himself, and he must be fought at every turn.

We should impeach him again, if nothing else. Maybe the Republicans are still too ideologically blinded or too corrupt to actually help us remove him from office, but making him even more historic in his number of impeachments still at least sends a message.

We should also get enough states to finally sign onto the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact to actually make it happen. With Democratic control of Congress and several states gaining Democratic trifectas—including Texas, a huge number of Electoral College votes—it should now be feasible to complete the compact and ensure that future Presidential elections are effectively done by popular vote. This would be a major triumph for “one person, one vote”, and had we done this before 2016, Trump would never have been in office in the first place. (Why do we need Congress? The Compacts Clause. Fortunately, the Compacts Clause does not require a bill to pass—Trump would obviously veto any such bill—but merely “consent of Congress”, which can bypass the President. It’s also possible that the Supreme Court could rule that the NPVIC doesn’t constitute the sort of “compact” intended by the clause, but given the current state of the court, I wouldn’t hold my breath on that.)

Our work is not done.

Protests must continue. Campaigns to call or write members of Congress must continue. We must ensure that the Democrats understand that this mandate we have given them is to undo all the damage Republicans have done, not simply return to a feeling of normalcy.

This is precisely what President Biden failed to do in 2021-2024. Yes, it was a relief to get Trump out of office. But the deeper problems were not addressed. They must now be addressed.

Of course, I don’t expect them to solve all our country’s problems—or even necessarily repair all the damage Trump in particular has done—in two years. But we need them to work as hard as humanly possible toward that goal, now and for as long as it takes to get the job done.

Hanlon’s Razor isn’t quite right

Sep 27 JDN 2461311

Hanlon’s Razor tells us:

Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.

This is almost right. In fact, it is close enough to right to be useful at solving the problem it was meant to solve. However, I have a different maxim that I believe improves upon it:

Never attribute to coordinated conspiracy that which is adequately explained by uncoordinated malice and/or stupidity.

This is also related to another maxim I have read, Grey’s Law:

Sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from malice.

The problem that Hanlon’s Razor exists to solve, I believe, is the fact that many people are innately conspiracy-minded: Whenever something bad happens, they like to attribute it to the mysterious workings of some coordinated cabal of evildoers.

But this is in fact a very improbable explanation; our prior probability on it should be quite low. Not zero, as coordinated conspiracies do happen on occasion; but low, as they don’t happen very often—and the larger and longer the conspiracy required to explain the outcome, the lower we should the probability. (Three evil people coordinating for a few weeks happens all the time. Three thousand evil people coordinating for ten years is almost impossible.)

Yet malice is not actually all that improbable. About 1% of men are full-blown psychopaths and 10% have psychopathic tendencies, and about 8% of men are rapists. Since psychopaths seem to be overrepresented in positions of power, the prior probability that a given CEO or head of state is a psychopath is more like 5%. So when a corporation or a government does something horrific, yes, stupidity is very likely to be involved—but so is malice.

If we follow Hanlon’s Razor too closely, we begin to look for reasons why horrible things are not the true intentions of the people who do them, when sometimes the cruelty is the point. We come to imagine that our enemies are simply foolish and benighted, and if we simply told them the truth they would be enlightened.

This is in fact how I used to think. The last decade proved me wrong.

It seems deeply ironic; when I was a teenager, I thought the world’s conflicts were fundamentally complicated and required nuanced understanding of multiple perspectives in order to resolve. But everything that Donald Trump and the Republicans who have enabled him have done over the last ten years has shown me that this is simply not always true. My naivete of youth was in being too charitable.

Sometimes the other side is just evil. Sometimes they really are motivated by nothing but craven selfishness, misogyny, xenophobia, and racism. Sometimes our leaders really are willing to support a corrupt, incompetent, deceitful, malevolent, racist, misogynist, fascist, pedophile rapist. (Are they corrupt? Has he threatened them? Are they doing this because they still somehow think he’ll be good for the economy? Do they simply hate the same people he hates? Does it even matter anymore? Someone who supports a fascist because he was bribed or thinks it will be good for the economy is still supporting a fascist.)

While I cannot say all his millions of supporters are evil, their failure at this point seems to go beyond any ordinary stupidity. It requires either that they do not know how terrible he is—which would require such profound willfull ignorance or gullibility that it is almost unfathomable to me—or that they do not care—which would make them so totally callous or misguided that in fact I should probably simply call them evil after all. Fortunately they only comprise about 40% of Americans, roughly the proportion who think the Earth is less than 10,000 years old—and yes, the two beliefs are very strongly correlated. So maybe they really, truly are that ignorant and gullible. They have been convinced of absurdities and so will happily excuse atrocities. Perhaps there is still some way to reach them, but I do not know what it is, and I do not think we have time to find out.

Sometimes our enemies cannot be reasoned with, and must simply be defeated—hopefully at the ballot box, but if it comes to it, sometimes even on the battlefield. (To be clear: I am not suggesting a violent overthrow of Donald Trump. I want Democrats to win both houses of Congress and remove him from office. But if they try to remove him and he refuses to be removed, or if he refuses to cede power to whoever wins in 2028, then yes, it would then be time to solve this conflict with guns.)


Want to support this blog? Join my Patreon, and get early access to all draft posts before they go live! https://www.patreon.com/c/pnrjulius

Somehow, the sanewashing continues

Jul 26 JDN 2461248

Since the very beginning, journalists have been sanewashing Trump and his cronies: Whenever he or one of them says something absolutely absurd, they always try to find some more sensible way of rephrasing it as a vaguely-similar concept that might actually be a potentially reasonable government policy.

To use one of many examples I could have pulled from, when Donald Trump gave an incoherent rant about immigrants invading our country to barbecue our cats and dogs, many news outlets reported it as things like “Trump escalates rhetoric on immigrants.” Is that what he did? Is it?

I even understand the impulse: In most circumstances, trying to be charitable and steelman your opponents’ ideas is healthy, productive, and good.

But sometimes, when someone just says something completely crazy, you need to quote them verbatim. You need people to know that what they said was, in fact, completely crazy. As journalists, you do the world a disservice otherwise.

Indeed, I think this was one of the reasons Trump was able to be so successful; low-information voters often only heard the sanewashed version of his ideas, and so he sounded like a fairly typical Republican: tough on crime, tough on immigration, serious about boosting the economy.

And while some news outlets are—slowly, all too slowly—getting better about this, spending more time quoting Trump directly and showing videos of him actually speaking and how demented he appears when doing so, there are still some mainstream outlets that are trying to sanewash him and his cronies.

I give you, Exhibit A: The Economist.

“Pete Hegseth’s testosterone-screening plan is unusual, not crazy”, they write.

Is that so? Is it?

They point out that soldiers are at elevated risk of hypogonadism, likely due to the extremely high physical and psychological stress of warfare. This much is absolutely true. But is it even relevant? Is that what Hegseth’s testosterone plan is actually about?

Clearly not. WIRED has their heads on straight: “Pete Hegseth’s Plan for ‘High T’ Troops Is a Junk-Science Fever Dream”.

Pete Hegseth did not consult a group of military endocrinologists or read the latest scientific research on stress-related hypogonadism when devising his latest policy. Nor, indeed, would he have come up with this policy had he done so: Military doctors already know how to screen for endocrine disorders, it is not difficult or expensive to do so, and they generally do so whenever a soldier exhibits symptoms that are consistent with such a disorder. Most soldiers obviously don’t need such screenings, and those that do, would need to be tested at multiple different times of day to track their hormone cycle (male hormone cycles are higher in both frequency and amplitude than female hormone cycles, so it’s honestly pretty weird that we think of women as “hormonal”), not simply get a one-time test every six months to see if the number is high enough. And even if a soldier does suffer from hypogonadism, any good endocrinologist will tell you that you don’t just jump straight to testosterone replacement therapy before trying anything else.

Thus, mass testing everyone in the military for testosterone and immediately offering hormone replacement therapy is neither necessary nor sufficient for actually treating the genuine physiological risks of warfare.

What it is necessary and sufficient for is something much, much stupider.

Testosterone is manly. Manly is good. Warriors must be more manly. More manly warriors win wars.

That, my friends, is the level of reasoning that went on inside Pete Hegseth’s pathetic, immature brain.

This is not a carefully considered medical policy developed under consultation with experts. This is a man physically has the body of an adult but never mentally matured beyond the age of 13 and still thinks that the ideal soldier looks like a GI Joe doll. (Excuse me, “action figure”.) He’s probably insecure about his own testosterone level (as that does tend to drop as you get older), likely is on (unnecessary) testosterone replacement therapy himself, and thinks that everyone should do this, because it’s just obvious to him that more testosterone equals more manly equals better.

Imagine a Neanderthal who had been given some vague inkling as to what testosterone is, enough to know that men have lots of it and women don’t. That is the kind of person we are dealing with here.

So, I say to you, The Economist, and every other news outlet:

STOP IT. STOP IT NOW.

You should have stopped 10 years ago, but better late than never. Stop it now.

When they do and say crazy things for crazy reasons, say that. Tell people. That is your job. Yes, we all wish that low-information voters were more responsible about gathering knowledge before voting (and thus stopped being low-information voters). But they aren’t going to do that any time soon, and it’s even understandable that they don’t (life is busy!). So please, make it easy for them: When the guy on one side of the aisle is a raving maniac, tell them that. Don’t expect them to figure it out for themselves.

(Really, I just wish that ignorant people would stop voting. If you can’t cast an informed vote, don’t cast a vote at all! You aren’t helping!)

Wonderful news from Hungary

Apr 19 JDN 246150

Hungary’s recent election results were just about as good as they could possibly have been. Victor Orban was not only defeated, but crushed; Magyar’s party didn’t just win, they won a supermajority. They now have the power to implement sweeping reforms that could prevent authoritarians like Orban from ever taking power in Hungary again.

Already Magyar has suspended Hungarian state media broadcasts and released $90 billion in EU aid for Ukraine that Hungary had been holding up. These are immediate, concrete results from just his first few days in office.

I have two goals for this post:

First, I just want to celebrate.

This is a huge victory for democracy, not just in Hungary, but across Europe and indeed around the world. It brings hope in a time when we needed it most. It proves to the world that authoritarians can be toppled, and democracy can be restored—sometimes even without bloodshed.

There is a light at the end of this tunnel. We must keep pressing forward.

Second, I want to use it as a model.

I think the biggest thing that this event teaches us is that democracy and nonviolence can succeed. This is something we should already have recognized from the empirical evidence, but rarely do we see such a clear, unambiguous example of a triumphant victory by nonviolent, democratic means alone.

Hungarians protested, and lobbied, and voted, and they did so in a united voice against Orban’s tyranny. But there was very little violence—and most of what there was, was instigated by the government against peaceful protesters. (Remember, nonviolence doesn’t mean nobody gets hurt.)

And once he took power, Magyar already began the process of reform. It will no doubt be a long and difficult process, and may take years to complete. Orban and his party are defeated, but not destroyed, and they will continue to mount resistance. But Magyar did not wait. He did not try to reconcile or compromise. He immediately set out to make things better.

This is what the Democrats must do when they win the midterm elections this year. They must not be timid and careful, not taking any bold moves to avoid upsetting “moderates”. (Anyone who still thinks Trump belongs anywhere near public office at this point is not and never was a moderate. At best, they might be a low-information voter who literally doesn’t know what’s going on.) They must act swiftly and decisively to repair the damage Trump has done and fix our system so that no similar maniac can do such damage again in the future. This is exactly what Biden failed to do when he took office in 2020. (Yes, I know that Congress and the Supreme Court fought him on a lot of things. But there was definitely still more that he could have done and didn’t, and people are suffering now because of it.)

Ideally, in fact, they would impeach and remove Trump before 2028. (And if it’s not too much trouble, try him at the Hague for all the children he starved?) But if they don’t manage to do that, at the very least, they must ensure that they continue to have such a strong campaign for Congress and the President in 2028 that they take both of those branches of government—and then, they need to pack the Supreme Court in order to secure the third. This damage will not be undone until Republicans are completely removed from the seats of national power, and stay removed for at least a decade.

Of course, in order for that to happen, the Democrats are going to need to win a lot of elections. And that isn’t just on them—it’s also on us. They need to run better candidates, we need to vote for those candidates, and we need to hold those candidates accountable for taking the bold measures necessary to repair America after this disaster. They need to stop taking their own electoral victories for granted: Yes, Clinton and Biden absolutely deserved to win all three elections. But they only actually won one of them, and that is what matters. The Democratic Party should be looking long and hard at what went wrong in 2016 and 2024, and learning from those mistakes.

I’m not even saying the Democrats are perfect; they are not. (Neither is Magyar.) But we need a powerful party to defeat the Republicans and restore American democracy, and only the Democrats are currently in a position to fulfill that role. After the Republicans are totally destroyed and only a distant, unsettling memory like the Nazis, then you can start voting for the Greens or the Libertarians.

And since “Magyar” basically just means “Hungarian”, maybe we should run a Presidential candidate named something like John T. American, just in case.

This is fascism.

Feb 1 JDN 2461073

The Party told you to ignore the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.

– George Orwell, 1984

As I write this, we haven’t even finished January of 2026, and already there have been not one, but two blatant, public executions of innocent people by federal agents that occurred in broad daylight and on video.

I already thought the video of Renee Good’s shooting was pretty clear, but the videos of Alex Pretti’s just leave no room for doubt at all. He was disarmed and restrained when they shot him; this was an execution.

I have heard liberals mocked by leftists as “people who are okay with the government killing people as long as the right paperwork is filed”. This is sort of true, actually—if by “paperwork” you mean due process of law. You know, the foundation of liberal democracy? That little thing?

Yes, I am actually okay with (some) military actions, police shootings in self-defense, and even executions of convicted murderers (though I should note that actually many liberals aren’t okay with the latter). I think that a world where nobody kills anybody is a pipe dream, and the best we can reasonably hope for is one where there are few killings, most of them are justified, and the ones that aren’t are punished. (And if your problem is specifically with the government killing people… who do you think should have that authority, if not democratically-elected representatives?) I understand that the government needs to kill people sometimes, but I expect those killings to be limited to justifiable wars, imminent threats to life and limb, or the result of a proper conviction by a fair jury trial.

But this was not due process of law. There was no judge, no jury, no trial—there wasn’t even a warrant or an arrest. Nor was it an in-the-moment response to an imminent threat—even a perceived one. The videos are crystal-clear: Alex Pretti was no threat to the border patrol agents who shot him to death.

This is fascism.

It’s not like fascism. It’s not toward fascism. This isn’t how it starts. Masked men executing innocent people in broad daylight is fascism. It’s here. It’s happening.

This does not necessarily mean that our entire country has fallen to fascism; there is still hope that we can stop this from happening again, and also hope that this will not escalate into a full-blown civil war. But shooting an innocent unarmed man without a judge or a jury is an inherently, irredeemably fascist act. If the men responsible are not tried for murder, it will be a grave injustice—and it could very well escalate into much larger-scale violence.

I wish I could say this sort of thing is totally unprecedented; but no, it’s not. The United States government has done a lot of horrible things over the years, from slavery to the Trail of Tears to the Japanese internment. I think that our country has been in a profound state of tension from the very beginning, between the high-minded ideals of “all men are created equal” and the deep-seated tribalism that comes naturally to nearly all human beings. I don’t think America is uniquely evil; in fact, I think we are especially good—it’s just that even a good country often does horrible things.

And there is something different about this. It’s not the first time our government has killed anyone, or even killed anyone for an obviously unjustified reason. But I think it might be the first time the government has publicly and blatantly lied about the circumstances in a way that can be directly refuted by video evidence. They aren’t painting it as a “mistake” or saying it was “a few bad apples”; they are actually trying to claim justification where obviously none exists. They are asking you to believe what they say over what you can see with your own two eyes.

This is what authoritarian states do. They try to undermine your belief in objective reality. They try to gaslight you into believing what they say instead of what you can see. And even in an extremely prosperous, well-educated country, they have been shockingly effective at it.

This is what we warned against when Trump was running for election.

Maybe it’s not productive to say “We told you so”, but, uh, we told you so.

He’s done so many terrible things, and has been enabled so many times by Republicans in Congress and the right-wing justices of the Supreme Court. As a result, it’s hard to draw any bright lines in the sand. But if you really want to draw one, this might be a good one to draw.

Honestly, the best time to turn against Trump was ten years ago; but people are finally turning against him, and better late than never.

Another year older

Jan 18 JDN 2461059

This post goes live one day before my 38th birthday. I think at this point I have to officially classify myself as middle-aged; I have nearly lived half the life I can expect to live. (Actually if you look at actuarial tables, the point at which, for a male, your expected remaining lifespan is equal to your age is 39 years old, so I’m not quite there yet.)

The odd part is I still don’t really feel like an adult. I don’t own my own home; I’m not making enough money to save; I don’t have any children. I am at least married, and I have a PhD; so I have at least achieved some of the milestones of adulthood—but not nearly as many as I’d expected to have achieved by the age of 38.

Then again, maybe growing older always feels like this. SMBC had a comic about this, where a woman grows older but always feels like she’s a child pretending to be older. But I don’t really feel like a child pretending to be an adult; I feel like a teenager pretending to be an adult. It’s as if my core identity was set at about the age of 16 and ever since then, time passes and my body keeps getting older, but I still feel like I’m that same person pretending to be someone else.

I think I felt more like an adult when I was teaching at Edinburgh; then at least I was working as a professional and paying my own rent. I wish I’d been able to find a way to be happy in academia, because I certainly haven’t found a way to be happy outside of it—and at least on the inside I was making money.

This last year in particular has been one of the worst in my lifetime—not just for me, but for the whole world.

For me personally: I lost one of my greatest mentors, I still remain unemployed, and my mother’s memory problems have not improved (though they also haven’t gotten worse).

For the world at large: Thanks to his enablers in the Republican Party, Donald Trump has been able to do tremendous damage to the United States, the global trade system, NATO, and global poverty relief efforts, with virtually no apparent gain to anyone but himself and perhaps a few of his closest cronies (though even them he would happily throw under the bus for an extra dollar).

I guess it remains to be seen what will happen to Venezuela; while Maduro was terrible, it’s quite clear that Trump does not have the best interests of the Venezuelan people at heart. He seems unwilling to even pretend that this is about anything but oil. (The weirdest part is that even the oil companies don’t actually seem all that interested in the oil!)

We have all watched helplessly as the carnage has ensued, getting news almost every single day about some new horrible thing that he has done. All the institutions that were supposed to stop this kind of madness have utterly failed in their task, most of all the Electoral College, which actually did the exact opposite of its intended purpose by electing him in the first place.

It’s not all Trump’s fault, either: The increase in US carbon emissions had less to do with Trump’s policies than with the war in Ukraine raising natural gas prices and data centers hogging our electricity.

It could be worse, I suppose. We still aren’t in World War 3. Congress is actually doing something to try to stop Trump from—I can’t believe I’m saying this—invading Greenland. And the recent increase in extreme poverty measures was a change in how poverty is measured, not a real reduction in standard of living; global extreme poverty is still decreasing (though also still horrifically high).

I still feel like I’m in survival mode: Just trying to get through each day, hoping that things eventually get better. But at least I get to have some cake with friends.

Hope for the new year

Jan 4 JDN 2461045

We have just entered 2026. I remember that around this time last year I felt a deep, visceral despair: Trump had just been elected and was about to be inaugurated, and I could only dread what the next year would bring. For the next several weeks I posted sections of my book The Logic of Kindness (at this point, it is probably never actually going to be published?), partly because I felt—and still feel—that these ideas do deserve to be out in the world, but also partly because I had no creative energy to write anything else.

Well, the first year of Trump’s second term was just about as bad as we thought it would be. He has torn apart global institutions that took decades to forge; he has caused thousands if not millions of unnecessary deaths; he has alienated our closest allies—seriously, CANADA!?—and cozied up to corrupt, authoritarian dictators around the world, because that is exactly what he aspires to be.

It’s true, he hasn’t collapsed the economy (yet). Inflation has been about as bad as it was before, despite the ludicrous tariffs. (He promised to bring prices down, but we all knew he wouldn’t. I honestly expected them to go up more than this.) He also hasn’t started any wars, though he looks damn close to it in Venezuela. And as he continues to make a mockery of our whole government, the checks and balances that are supposed to be reining him have languished unused, because the Republicans control all three branches.

Trump is still in office, and poised to be for three more years.

Yet, at last, there is some glimmer of hope on the horizon.

Other Republicans are starting to turn against him, in part because of his obvious and undeniable connections to Jeffrey Epstein and his ring of serial rapists. (Let’s be clear about that, by the way: They’re not just pedophiles. “Pedophile” merely means you are sexually attracted to children. Some pedophiles seek treatment. These men were rapists who sexually assaulted actual teenagers. And at this point it strains credulity to imagine that Donald Trump himself wasn’t an active participant on multiple occasions—no amount of incompetent redactions will change that.)

Trump’s net approval is now negative on almost every major issue, especially on inflation. It is now a statistical certainty that more Americans disapprove of him than approve of him.

Both of these things should have happened more than a year ago, if not a decade ago; but hey, better late than never.

Democrats—even very left-wing democrats, like Mamdani—have done very well in elections lately, and seem poised to continue doing well in the 2026 midterm election. If we can actually secure a majority in both houses of Congress, we might finally be able to start undoing some of the damage Trump has done—or at least stop him from doing even more.

I’m sure there will be plenty of bad things that continue to happen this year, and that many of them will be Donald Trump’s fault. But I no longer feel the deep despair I felt last year; it seems like things might finally be turning around for America—and thus for the world.

The longest night

Dec 21 JDN 2461031

When this post goes live, it will be (almost exactly) the winter solstice in the Northern Hemisphere. In our culture, derived mainly from European influences, we associate this time of year with Christmas; but in fact solstice celebrations are much more ancient and universal than that. Humans have been engaging in some sort of ritual celebration—often involving feasts and/or gifts—around the winter solstice in basically every temperate region of the world for as far back as we are able to determine. (You don’t see solstice celebrations so much in tropical regions, because “winter” isn’t really a thing there; those cultures tend to adopt lunar or lunisolar calendars instead.) Presumably humans have been doing something along these lines for about as long as there have been humans to do them.

I think part of why solstice celebrations are so enduring is that the solstice has both powerful symbolism and practical significance. It is the longest night of the year, when the sky will be darkest for the longest time and light for the shortest—above the Arctic Circle, the night lasts 24 hours and the sky never gets light at all. But from that point forward, the light will start to return. The solstice also heralds the start of the winter months, when the air is cold enough to be dangerous and food becomes much scarcer.

Of course, today we don’t have to worry about that so much: We have electric heating and refrigeration, so we can stay warm inside and eat pretty much whatever we want all year round. The practical significance, then, of the solstice has greatly decreased for us.

Yet it’s still a very symbolic time: The darkness is at its worst, the turning point is reached, the light will soon return. And when we reflect on how much safer we are than our ancestors were during this time of year, we may find it in our hearts to feel some gratitude for how far humanity has come—even if we still have terribly far yet to go.

And this year, in particular, I think we are seeing the turning point for a lot of darkness. The last year especially has been a nightmare for, well, the entire free world—not to mention all the poor countries who depended on us for aid—but at last it seems like we are beginning to wake from that nightmare. Within margin of error, Trump’s approval rating is at the lowest it has ever been, about 43% (still shockingly high, I admit), and the Republicans seem to be much more divided and disorganized than they were just a year ago, some of them even openly defying Trump instead of bowing at his every word.

Of course, while the motions of the Earth are extraordinarily regular and predictable, changes in society are not. The solstice will certainly happen on schedule, and the days will certainly get longer for the next six months after that—I’d give you million-to-one odds on either proposition. (Frankly, if I ever had to pay, we’d probably have bigger problems!)

But as far as our political, economic, and cultural situation, things could get very well get worse again before they get better. There’s even a chance they won’t get better, that it’s all downhill from here—but I believe those chances are very small. Things are not so bleak as that.

While there have certainly been setbacks and there will surely be more, on the whole humanity’s trajectory has been upward, toward greater justice and prosperity. Things feel so bad right now, not so much because they are bad in absolute terms (would you rather live as a Roman slave or a Medieval peasant?), but because this is such a harsh reversal in an otherwise upward trend—and because we can see just how easy it would be to do even better still, if the powers that be had half the will to do so.

So here’s hoping that on this longest night, at least some of the people with the power to make things better will see a little more of the light.

The confidence game

Dec 14 JDN 2461024

Our society rewards confidence. Indeed, it seems to do so without limit: The more confident you are, the more successful you will be, the more prestige you will gain, the more power you will have, the more money you will make. It doesn’t seem to matter whether your confidence is justified; there is no punishment for overconfidence and no reward for humility.

If you doubt this, I give you Exhibit A: President Donald Trump.

He has nothing else going for him. He manages to epitomize almost every human vice and lack in almost every human virtue. He is ignorant, impulsive, rude, cruel, incurious, bigoted, incompetent, selfish, xenophobic, racist, and misogynist. He has no empathy, no understanding of justice, and little capacity for self-control. He cares nothing for truth and lies constantly, even to the point of pathology. He has been convicted of multiple felonies. His businesses routinely go bankrupt, and he saves his wealth mainly through fraud and lawsuits. He has publicly admitted to sexually assaulting adult women, and there is mounting evidence that he has also sexually assaulted teenage girls. He is, in short, one of the worst human beings in the world. He does not have the integrity or trustworthiness to be an assistant manager at McDonald’s, let alone President of the United States.

But he thinks he’s brilliant and competent and wise and ethical, and constantly tells everyone around him that he is—and millions of people apparently believe him.

To be fair, confidence is not the only trait that our society rewards. Sometimes it does actually reward hard work, competence, or intellect. But in fact it seems to reward these virtues less consistently than it rewards confidence. And quite frankly I’m not convinced our society rewards honesty at all; liars and frauds seem to be disproportionately represented among the successful.

This troubles me most of all because confidence is not a virtue.

There is nothing good about being confident per se. There is virtue in notbeing underconfident, because underconfidence prevents you from taking actions you should take. But there is just as much virtue in not being overconfident, because overconfidence makes you take actions you shouldn’t—and if anything, is the more dangerous of the two. Yet our culture appears utterly incapable of discerning whether confidence is justifiable—even in the most blatantly obvious cases—and instead rewards everyone all the time for being as confident as they can possibly be.

In fact, the most confident people are usually less competent than the most humble people—because when you really understand something, you also understand how much you don’t understand.

We seem totally unable to tell whether someone who thinks they are right is actually right; and so, whoever thinks they are right is assumed to be right, all the time, every time.

Some of this may even be genetic, a heuristic that perhaps made more sense in our ancient environment. Even quite young children already are more willing to trust confident answers than hesitant ones, in multiple experiments.

Studies suggest that experts are just as overconfident as anyone else, but to be frank, I think this is because you don’t get to be called an expert unless you’re overconfident; people with intellectual humility are filtered out by the brutal competition of academia before they can get tenure.

I guess this is also personal for me.

I am not a confident person. Temperamentally, I just feel deeply uncomfortable going out on a limb and asserting things when I’m not entirely certain of them. I also have something of a complex about ever being perceived as arrogant or condescending, maybe because people often seem to perceive me that way even when I am actively trying to do the opposite. A lot of people seem to take you as condescending when you simply acknowledge that you have more expertise on something than they do.

I am also apparently a poster child for Impostor Syndrome. I once went to an Impostor Syndrome with a couple dozen other people where they played a bingo game for Impostor Syndrome traits and behaviors—and won. I once went to a lecture by George Akerlof where he explained that he attributed his Nobel Prize more to luck and circumstances than any particular brilliance on his part—and I guarantee you, in the extremely unlikely event I ever win a prize like that, I’ll say the same.

Compound this with the fact that our society routinely demands confidence in situations where absolutely no one could ever justify being confident.

Consider a job interview, when they ask you: “Why are you the best candidate for this job?” I couldn’t possibly know that. No one in my position could possibly know that. I literally do not know who your other candidates are in order to compare myself to them. I can tell you why I am qualified, but that’s all I can do. I could be the best person for the job, but I have no idea if I am. It’s your job to figure that out, with all the information in front of you—and I happen to know that you’re actually terrible at it, even with all that information I don’t have access to. If I tell you I know I’m the best person for the job, I am, by construction, either wildly overconfident or lying. (And in my case, it would definitely be lying.)

In fact, if I were a hiring manager, I would probably disqualify anyone who told me they were the best person for the job—because the one thing I now know about them is that they are either overconfident or willing to lie. (But I’ll probably never be a hiring manager.)

Likewise, I’ve been often told when pitching creative work to explain why I am the best or only person who could bring this work to life, or to provide accurate forecasts of how much the work would sell if published. I almost certainly am not the best or only person who could do anything—only a handful of people on Earth could realistically say that they are, and they’ve all already won Oscars or Emmys or Nobel Prizes. Accurate sales forecasts for creative works are so difficult that even Disney Corporation, an ever-growing conglomerate media superpower with billions of dollars to throw at the problem and even more billions of dollars at stake in getting it right, still routinely puts out films that are financial failures.


They casually hand you impossible demands and then get mad at you when you say you can’t meet them. And then they go pick someone else who claims to be able to do the impossible.

There is some hope, however.

Some studies suggest that people can sometimes recognize and punish overconfidence—though, again, I don’t see how that can be reconciled with the success of Donald Trump. In this study of evaluating expert witnesses, the most confident witnesses were rated as slightly less reliable than the moderately-confident ones, but both were far above the least-confident ones.

Surprisingly simple interventions can make intellectual humility more salient to people, and make them more willing to trust people who express doubt—who are, almost without exception, the more trustworthy people.

But somehow, I think I have to learn to express confidence I don’t feel, because that’s how you succeed in our society.